Vortex Formation in Ellipsoidal Thermal Bubbles

Alan Shapiro
School of Meteorology (SOM) and Center for Analysis and Prediction of Storms (CAPS), University of Oklahoma, Norman OK
&
Katharine M. Kanak
School of Meteorology, University of Oklahoma, Norman OK


ABSTRACT

     The rise of an isolated dry thermal bubble in a quiescent unstratified environment is a prototypical natural convective flow.  This study considers the rise of an isolated dry thermal bubble of ellipsoidal shape (elliptical in both horizontal and vertical cross-sections).  The azimuthal asymmetry of the bubble allows the vorticity tilting mechanism to operate without an environmental wind.  The dry Boussinesq equations of motion are solved analytically as a Taylor series in time for the short-term behavior of the bubble (involving derivatives of up to the third-order in time).  The analytic results are supplemented with numerical simulations to examine longer-term behavior.  The first non-zero term in the Taylor expansion for the vertical vorticity is a third-order term, and appears as a four-leaf clover pattern with lobes of alternating sign.  The horizontal flow associated with this vorticity pattern first appears as a sheared stagnation point-type flow, but eventually organizes into vertical vortices that fill the bubble.  The vortices induce large structural changes to the bubble, and eventually reverse the sense of the azimuthal asymmetry.



An article on this work appeared in the Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences:

Shapiro, A., and K. M. Kanak, 2002:  Vortex formation in elliptical thermal bubbles.   J. Atmos. Sci., 59, 2253–2269.

and was presented at the
Symposium on Environmental Hydraulics:

Shapiro, A., and K. M. Kanak, 2002:  Vortex formation in elliptical thermal bubbles.   Third International Symposium on Environmental Hydraulics, Tempe, AZ, December 2001.



A suite of numerical experiments were conductedin which the sizes and ellipticities of the intial thermal bubbles were varied. Sample results of the animations from two of these experiments are provded below.

All animations contain sequences in time of XY-plane contour fields chosen at the (increasing) heights of the levels of domain maximum vertical vorticity.
 
EXPT 1 (Tall Bubble in XZ and YZ planes)
EXPT 4 (Shallow Bubble in XZ and YZ planes)
YZ - Animation of the potential temperature field - Expt 1
YZ - Animation of the potential temperature field - Expt 4
XY - Animation of the horizontal velocity vectors - Expt 1
XY - Animation of the horizontal velocity vectors - Expt 4

The second author was supported by NSF ATM-9727150 and by the Cooperative Institute for Mesoscale Meteorological Studies.

Recently the work has been expanded by M.S. student Allison P. Silveira.  As part of her thesis work she carried out a suite of experiments in which an ambient wind shear was added to the simulations presented in Shapiro and Kanak 2002.  She is currently preparing an article for publication on her work.

Last updated: 12-05

Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s)
 and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.